Gantry 5

 

Bulletin N°65 2026  The staunchly pro-Macron newspaper Le Monde published an article on September 21 entitled "  One year after the recognition of the State of Palestine, France's initiative has lost its panache,  " essentially taking stock of the Franco-Saudi operation at the UN in September 2025, dubbed, like many politicians, "recognition of Palestine." The article is a perfect example of the journalistic line adopted, especially among its microcosm of colleagues, to defend a balanced position on the colonial war in Palestine, what they call the "Israeli-Palestinian conflict." It reveals a profound disconnect from reality, from the history of Palestine, from colonial issues, and also a complete misunderstanding of who the defenders of Palestine are; and at the same time, here and there, admissions about the true nature of the French imperialist state's policy on the question of Palestine.
 
A partial and biased presentation
Not without a certain enthusiasm for the occupant of the Élysée Palace, referring to the Franco-Saudi resolution adopted in September 2025 by the UN General Assembly, the two authors of the article tell us: “  The head of state had then convinced about ten countries to follow him. ‘ The time has come , ’ he had explained. Emmanuel Macron, whom his entourage describes as haunted by the mark he will leave on history, perhaps thought, that day, that his words would resonate as strongly as those of the former Minister of Foreign Affairs Dominique de Villepin, who, in 2003, opposed the war in Iraq, which was instigated by the United States for dubious reasons.  ” We will revel, among other things, in the description of Macron as "haunted by the mark he will leave on history," as if the journalists at Le Monde were completely unaware of the disrepute he faces among French workers, as well as the "false motives" for the destruction of Iraq, without any further details. The colonial war, we learn, contrary to all reality (this is of course not the term used by the journalists), "  had, in Emmanuel Macron's eyes, turned into ' barbarity . ' It was necessary to act, to establish a semblance of a balance of power with Benjamin Netanyahu's government to save the two-state solution, diplomats from the Quai d'Orsay and the Élysée Palace were whispering to him.  "
Let's get back to reality and, more importantly, to what Macron's true intentions were during the political maneuver of the Franco-Saudi resolution of September 2025, because, of course, journalists aren't saying a word about it. Let's remember the mountain of conditions attached to this recognition, let's remember that Macron, as stated in the resolution, demanded and imposed a demilitarized Palestinian state, and practically dictated its mode of operation, modeled on the "universal model" of Western bourgeois democracies. He even went so far as to demand a review of school textbooks and the cessation of funding for the families of captives kidnapped by the Zionist occupation army. In short, Macron recognized a bantustan.
We are at the heart of the lie with this sentence: "  As if he admitted that the recognition of the State of Palestine, this grand gesture he had so hoped for, had not had the desired effect ." By playing on Macron's well-known narcissism, Le Monde tries to make us believe that he launched an initiative from which he expected results in the direction of peace. Macron is certainly not the most brilliant of the Fifth Republic's presidents , let's not mistake him for a fool. He never expected anything positive for peace from his initiative. On the contrary, it was a move aimed at allowing the Zionist colonial entity to finish off Gaza. No one who was even slightly aware of the reality of occupied Palestine and the ongoing genocide could believe that anything would come of this initiative, apart from burying the previous year's resolution (September 2024) demanding the withdrawal of Zionist occupation troops from the Gaza Strip.
 
A misleading presentation of the relationship between French imperialism and the Zionist colonial state
The article's authors try to make us believe that it was after this recognition that the Élysée Palace and French diplomacy began making gestures toward the genocidal Zionists: "  France's recognition of Palestine nearly degenerated into a severe diplomatic crisis between Paris and the Jewish state, which was outraged by this gesture, perceived as a purely egotistical presidential maneuver. To avoid exacerbating the situation and preventing Israel from carrying out its threat to close the consulate in Jerusalem, France has made numerous conciliatory gestures, contributing to muddying its message.  " It doesn't even occur to the journalists that France could have reacted by imposing sanctions, like Spain or Ireland. But above all, the article never once mentions colonization, nor the role  played by the multinational corporations of Western imperialist states, of which the Zionist colonial entity is both creation and creation. Forgotten are we talking about the "coalition against Hamas," Dupond-Moretti's circular against Palestinian liberation activists in October 2023, the massive state repression that followed, and the expulsion of Mariam Abu Daqqa? Forgotten are we talking about the supposed "inalienable right of Israel to defend itself," and the relentless efforts to keep Georges Abdallah in prison?
The French imperialist state, the fringe of the ruling class that installed Macron in power, has been, from the outset, in the camp of colonialists, genocidal perpetrators, and Zionist fascists. Even if the colonial ideology of our imperialism plays a significant role, we must, as always, look for the economic causes: our "companies" are actors in the colonization of Palestine, directly or indirectly, from BNP Paribas to Carrefour, including L'Oréal, Danone, Chanel, Evian, Yoplait, and Zara. The sinister Barrot just published, on the same day, September 21st, a statement deploring the death of an aggressor settler in the West Bank. The statement, referring to "France"—a concept that is becoming increasingly colonial, signifying ever more French imperialism—"  reiterates its condemnation of terrorism in all its forms  " and speaks of a "  terrorist attack that cost the life of an Israeli in the West Bank  ," without, of course, using the term "settler" or mentioning their role. Never before have we had such a statement deploring the daily assassinations of Palestinians in Gaza or the West Bank; at least seven occurred on the same day, and there was radio silence. And this has been the case since October 2023. If further proof were needed that the French imperialist state is and always has been on the side of the Zionists and has never deviated one iota from this line, here it is.
The so-called controversy following the recognition of a bantustan was nothing but a smokescreen for fools. As is the so-called decision to impose sanctions on products from Zionist settlements in Palestine, sparing the colonial state, and whose implementation is unclear because the Zionists manipulate the labeling—this, of course, Le Monde conveniently omits.
And the evening daily adopts all the codes of official Zionist propaganda; this single fragment of a sentence sums it up: “  The war in Gaza, waged by the Jewish state in retaliation for the massacre of October 7, 2023, perpetrated by Hamas  .” Everything is there: the “war in Gaza,” not genocide or colonial war; “the Jewish state” to designate the Zionist colonial entity; “retaliation” to justify the umpteenth Zionist attack against Gaza; “massacre” to describe the uprising of the armed Resistance on October 7, 2023; and finally, “Hamas” instead of the Resistance. Having itself been, from the beginning, a supporter of the genocidal colonial entity, but, as the truth unfolds, finding it increasingly difficult to acknowledge this, Le Monde prefers to see a shift in Macron’s political actions, so that the veil is not lifted on the two long years for the Palestinians that preceded the recognition of the bantustan.
Finally, like any media outlet respectful of the conventions of French imperialism, Le Monde is subject to the taboo surrounding words. We know that the word that must neither be written nor uttered is "genocide." The Macron supporters at the "newspaper of record" are no exception. But they take it quite far. Here's how the authors of the article express themselves regarding the era of "recognition": "  At a time when the State of Israel was waging a war of annihilation in Gaza  ." Between a war of annihilation and genocide, the difference seems, to say the least, tenuous. Note in passing the use of the imperfect tense, which seems to implicitly suggest that the war of annihilation has been paused since the pseudo-ceasefire. But honor is preserved; the word was written only in quotation marks, à la Sophia Aram, in a single sentence that in no way commits the newspaper's editorial staff: "  In February 2026, the Quai d'Orsay called for the resignation of the UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Territories, Francesca Albanese, denouncing the jurist's offensive stances, who, in October 2025, had accused Israel of perpetrating a ' genocide ' in Gaza.  " Nevertheless, this same sentence clearly tells us that the word is taboo for the leaders of the French imperialist state and their ideological relays, including Le Monde .
 
The "defenders of Palestine"
To fully understand the position of the article's authors, here is a key sentence: "  In his desire to ease relations with Israel, French President Emmanuel Macron has muddled his message and disappointed advocates of the Palestinian cause.  " Thus, these "advocates of the Palestinian cause" supposedly believed in his recognition, unaware that it was a maneuver working against the Palestinians, and therefore, inevitably, were disappointed. As we have often written, there are advocates and then there are advocates of the Palestinian cause. The statement is not inaccurate if we consider the advocates promoted by the dominant ideology, the colonialists of good intentions, the "left," oscillating between "  It's a first step, but it's not enough, we need action!  " (the collective for a just and lasting peace between Palestinians and Israelis), at worst, and "  This recognition will have been nothing but a smokescreen intended to mask his complicity with Israel and to divert attention from his responsibilities ." "(Rima Hassan), at best."
Those who advocate for the liberation of Palestine from the river to the sea, like the Revolutionary Communist Party, have never been fooled. Not only is this not a first step, but it's not merely a smokescreen either. The smokescreen lies primarily in the presentation of a supposedly personal initiative, when in reality there was a real power imbalance that forced them, at best, to feign action. But what Macron did is neither a pretense nor a smokescreen. He reduced the concept of a Palestinian state to a tiny bantustan, a plaything in the hands of Western imperialists, and in exchange obtained an unjust Arab League resolution (we'll come back to this later) and the end of funding by the PA (Palestinian Authority) for a significant number of families of Palestinian hostages imprisoned in the sinister Zionist jails. He also, with the active complicity of the Saudi kings, ensured that the 2024 resolution was objectively erased; it demanded the withdrawal of Zionist occupation forces from the Gaza Strip, and paved the way, as we wrote at the time, for Trump's sordid "peace plan," enabling a Security Council resolution voted on by France, envisioning the total domination of the Zionist colonial entity over Gaza.
So, the true defenders of Palestine immediately saw where Macron was going with this, and were therefore never disappointed. But, upon closer examination, Le Monde found, probably within the circle of the compradors in Ramallah, a Palestinian woman supporting his rhetoric, going even further than the concept of a just and sustainable collective: "  France 's gesture was highly symbolic, but it hasn't changed the dynamics in Gaza , " asserts Inès Abdel Razek, co-director of the Palestine Institute for Public Diplomacy, adding that the sanctions announced in early September 2026 by the United Kingdom and a dozen other countries, including France, on products from Israeli settlements will be more effective in beginning to exert pressure on Israel.  But, of course, it is precisely this kind of collaborator, just like Abbas and his band of profiteers, that Le Monde is trying to pass off as genuine "defenders of the Palestinian cause." We reiterate this: any position that does not call for the dismantling of the Zionist colonial state is a colonial position, which allows the survival of the creature of Western imperialists and perpetuates colonization.
 
Confessions in the middle of the scaffolding
Through the article, despite its contradictions, the truth nevertheless emerges. First, with this: "  Intense work had been carried out in the preceding months to try to obtain, in exchange for France's recognition of the State of Palestine, reciprocal recognition of Israel by Muslim countries, including Saudi Arabia. In vain.  " Here we see one of the true aims of Macron's maneuver last autumn. Given the context of the time, where Arab leaders, even the oil magnates, have populations they cannot entirely afford to alienate, it was out of the question that this would be possible. But be that as it may, Macron has nonetheless earned his keep from Western imperialism: “  Paris had, however, managed to secure, with the help of its Saudi partner, the ‘ New York Declaration , ’ signed in July by the Arab League countries, including Qatar and Egypt, condemning the October 7 attack, calling for the disarmament of Hamas, and ruling out the Islamist movement contributing to the future governance of Gaza. Combined with the Palestinian Authority’s commitment to carry out reforms and hold elections, the UN roadmap was deemed sufficient to justify recognition.  ” This time, we have almost the whole truth. Quite clearly, this is not about recognizing Palestine, but about eliminating the Resistance in order to hand Gaza over to the Zionists. Two things are missing: the reality of the so-called State of Palestine, a rump bantustan, and the logical next step in the resolution, the Trump plan. While it's impossible for Le Monde to denounce the former, probably because, as good colonialists of Western bourgeois democracies, heirs to Voltaire, the editors find this bantustan legitimate, on the other hand, the Macron-Trump connection is handed to us on a silver platter. It couldn't be clearer: "  We saved the two-state solution , " a close associate of the president nevertheless boasts. At the Élysée Palace, they want to believe that France will have made history by preserving this diplomatic horizon, more nebulous than ever. The peace plan for Gaza brandished by the American president, Donald Trump, on September 29, 2025, establishing a ceasefire that was never respected, is supposedly proof: the text mentions, almost in passing, the possibility of a Palestinian state, which allowed the UN Security Council to endorse it with a resolution passed in November  .
Then, in a chapter entitled “  Maintaining a Balanced Posture  ,” the authors roll out the red carpet for French diplomacy and its minister, who are making efforts to introduce democracy into the Palestinian Authority, as if this were the crux of the problem. “  More discreetly, for the past year, French diplomats have been working to secure the future of the Palestinian side, helping to prepare for the succession of 90-year-old President Mahmoud Abbas. Paris has offered its assistance in drafting a Palestinian constitution and supported reforms in preparation for the first elections in the territories since 2006: legislative elections are scheduled for November 2026, followed by a presidential election. Against the Abbas clan, which is already working to postpone them, the French Foreign Minister, Jean-Noël Barrot, reiterated in early September the “ vital ” importance of these elections in the midst of war and warned that they could not be canceled “ under any pretext .  ” Here we have a major new admission: like good colonialists, French leaders are convinced that the Palestinians cannot draft a constitution themselves and that they need the help of Western experts . "The white man's burden," as Kipling said. The minister's tone, it should be noted, bluntly reveals that even if the Palestinians continue to be attacked by settlers, killed by the occupying army, and the Zionist entity can seize three-quarters of the West Bank, none of this can justify postponing the elections. How can we dictate our way of thinking to the Palestinians while utterly disregarding their living conditions and the daily death threats they endure, which often come true? Finally, this sheds light on Le Monde 's concept of a balanced stance: everything for the Zionists, nothing for the Palestinians.
We can't resist, for the sake of the discerning reader, presenting this final excerpt: "  Deep down, the Élysée Palace never imagined that its maneuver would lead the State of Israel to change its policy ." One can hardly contradict oneself after having waxed lyrical about the hopes of Macron and, presumably, his journalist supporters. But, as they say, light comes from contradiction; this is quite fitting for this passage.
 
In conclusion
However, these important pieces of truth thus revealed are not free from the same fallacious presentation of reality. For example, this assertion: "  Today's Israel is no longer the Israel of the Oslo Accords," a diplomat acknowledges, "when the Jewish state was concerned with its place among the triumphant democracies of the post-Cold War era.  " This is simply one of the ritual attempts, particularly by "left-wing" Zionists, to make us believe that the Zionist colonial entity has changed, that it was once benign, but has been corrupted or lost because of the villainous "far-right Netanyahu."
One could also suggest that the statement, placed in the mouth of someone close to the president, regarding the preservation of the two-state solution, deserved at least to be questioned, especially when the French-born US diplomat, Robert Malley, former Middle East advisor to Clinton, Obama, and Biden, declared on France Inter: “  For years, all leaders, especially Western leaders, have been talking about the two-state solution. Yet on the ground, we are constantly regressing, settlement activity continues, Palestinian and Israeli minds continue to diverge, so we talk about it, but we talk about it almost as a pretext for doing nothing. […] At first, I think it's an illusion, but when an illusion continues for 20-30 years, it becomes a deception.  ” Le Monde, it should be noted, also published an article discussing the book he recently released on the subject, co-authored with Hussein Agha, a former Palestinian negotiator in the process following the Oslo Accords debacle. It was clearly impossible to let this claim of rescue go unchallenged.
In reality, neither Macron nor Le Monde ever believed that this pseudo-recognition could be of any use whatsoever to the Palestinians. Moreover, they couldn't care less about their plight. But the dusting off of the rug by Operation "Al-Aqsa Flood," the revelation of what the Zionist colonial entity truly is, the Zionist enterprise from the very beginning, forces them to feign interest and adopt a balanced stance that fools no one. The conclusion one can draw from reading this article is this: decidedly, there is nothing to expect from Macron regarding the liberation of Palestine, as on other issues, but his ideological mouthpieces are vainly trying to make us believe otherwise.
 
We say it again: the Palestinian Resistance fighters are battling the same enemy that oppresses us: Western imperialism. Their victory would be a powerful signal for our own emancipation. A people fighting for their national liberation, against a creature of Western imperialists, is also fighting against colonialism and its ideological presuppositions that are now poisoning the entire French "left."
For the Revolutionary Communist Party, the struggle of the Palestinian Resistance, which directly confronts the vanguard of Western imperialism, is vital for the proletariat of the entire planet; the Palestinians are a people who are actors in their own history, fighting against Zionism, imperialism and reaction, for their national liberation, a long struggle whose centrality and strategic nature for our own emancipation we must recognize.